Hello dear
Welcome To The Independent Pizzeria
At The Independent Pizzeria, we celebrate the heart and soul of authentic Italian pizza. Nestled in Seattle, this charming eatery is adorned with the aroma of wood-fired crusts and fresh ingredients. Each pizza, from the classic Village to the standout clam variety, encapsulates the essence of quality craftsmanship. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, we offer takeout, reservations, and outdoor seating, ensuring a delightful experience for families and groups alike. Our devoted patrons rave about the exceptional Caesar salad and tiramisu, cementing us as a local gem. Join us at 4235 E Madison St and savor a slice of passion!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Matthews Cuvee Red (WA)
$25.00Loimer Gruner Veltliner (Austria)
$20.00Queen
$14.00
The Village
$12.00Mixed Greens
$7.00Caesar Salad
$6.00
Castelevetrano Olives
$5.00Topo Chico Mineral Water
$3.00Blue Sky Organic Cola
$3.00 About
The Independent Pizzeria
Welcome to The Independent Pizzeria, a delightful sanctuary for pizza lovers nestled in the vibrant locale of Seattle at 4235 E Madison St. If you are seeking authentic Italian pizza crafted with precision and passion, look no further. This pizzeria has captured the hearts and palates of many, establishing itself as a must-visit haven for those craving an exceptional dining experience.
At The Independent Pizzeria, every element is thoughtfully curated. Guests can begin their journey with enticing starters like the Caesar Salad, perfectly paired with fresh romaine, grated cheese, and house-made dressing for just $6.00. Alternatively, the Mixed Greens salad, adorned with tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, and artichokes, offers a refreshing start at $7.00. Don't forget the Castelevetrano Olives, which boast a bright flavor, served in their brine for a mere $5.00.
The true stars here, however, are the pizzas. Renowned for their wood-fired crusts, each pie is a symphony of flavors and fresh ingredients. The Village pizza, featuring mozzarella at just $12.00, and the Queen pizza, abundant with fresh mozzarella and basil for $14.00, are testament to the pizzeria's commitment to excellence. Customers rave about the clam pizza in particular, highlighting its standout flavors and expert preparation.
Pair your meal with a fine selection of wines, such as the crisp Loimer Gruner Veltliner from Austria for $20.00 or the balanced Matthews Cuvee Red from Washington available for $25.00. These options elevate the dining experience, providing the perfect complement to your meal.
Client testimonials capture the essence of what makes The Independent Pizzeria unique. As one patron aptly put it, it’s “truly a hidden gem in Seattle for real authentic Italian pizza.” Others have expressed how the “fresh, hot, cooked-to-perfection” pizzas create a craving that lingers long after the last bite. While the ordering process might require some advance planning, rest assured that the wait amplifies the anticipation for what’s to come.
Beyond the pizza, the establishment is known for its exceptional sides. One enthusiastic reviewer remarked about the “best Caesar salad” in Seattle, complemented by “insane” bread. The tiramisu has also garnered praise, often declared the best of its kind in the city — each generous portion a tantalizing delight that rounds out the meal.
As you step into The Independent Pizzeria, you’re not just entering a restaurant; you’re immersing yourself in a culinary experience that champions authenticity and flavor. Whether you’re a local or simply visiting, this pizzeria has something to offer everyone. So, grab your friends, savor a slice of pizza, and let the flavors transport you to the heart of Italy.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Truly a hidden gem in Seattle for real authentic Italian pizza. The base, the sauce and fresh ingredients will definitely have me coming back as much as possible. I really wish them all the success because Seattle needs more places that make real pizza. ”
“ This little gem is simply the best. The pizzas were fresh, hot, cooked to perfection. The toppings are generous and the value proposition is exceptional you get what you pay for here. It is the kind of place I wish I could patronize weekly unfortunately we are only in town for a few days this trip. We will eat here every time we return. ”
“ Some of the best pizza in Seattle. The clam pizza is a notable standout. Their ordering experience leaves much to be desired, but once youre accustomed its no big deal. Its a bit strange that I have to place an order for pizza many many hours in advance. Lucky for me, Ive ALWAYS got pizza on the mind. ”
“ This place certainly lived up to the expectations and other reviews. Delicious wood fired crusts and wonderful toppings. A little on the greasy side for a traditional Neapolitan but that didnt detract from the experience or flavor at all. In fact, Im determined to go back and get some with meat as Im sure itd be wonderful. Enjoyed the location as well! Perfect to order up and then walk over and enjoy the water. ”
“ I love pizza, and this is my favorite pizza in Seattle. We always have the oven on when doing takeout to put the pizza in right away because its best enjoyed hot and fresh. We had the New Haven this time again and its legit so good. I also HAVE to mention their sides. The Caesar salad and the bread that comes with it. Holy mackerel. Again its the best Caesar salad Ive had in Seattle and they bread is insane next level stuff. Lastly, I mention the tiramisu. I hate to sound like a broken record but its the best Ive had in Seattle. Generous portion good because its pricey. Im always blown away by Independent Pizzeria. Highly highly recommend. ”
“ Great place! The dough is chewy and crisp on the outside. The toppings on the four pies Ive had have been great. To top it off, the prices are pretty good for Seattle! So may find the charring a little much. ”
“ Love this place. Been here 4 times and pizza has been great every time. They mostly do take out orders but have some outdoor seating for nice days. ”
“ Its a jewel here in Seattle! Great staffs work here. Their Margherita is one of the best Ive ever had including the places we tried in Italy! Id come here at least once a week if this place was in Vancouver. ”